ETH Library Idea Contests

3D Printing on demand

Sure, I have sent an email. Please feel free to remove this idea.

2 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

New ETH Mug Design

Sure, I have sent an email. Please feel free to remove this idea.

2 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

Thanks Annette for the feedback and questions!
- Let's include very brief info in the list view and detailed info in the detailed view. Brief info could include average rating or ranking in a specific category, e.g. "ranked #2 in Fluid Dynamics"
- I would be willing to share department and status information. Since that info is already linked to my ETH account, I wouldn't even have to type it in myself. (hopefully)
- You're right. This feature should be available for all material.

4 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

Book ratings and statistics

Thanks for the feedback!

4 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

Dataset documentation quality assessment for Digital Curation

Fully agree!

4 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

Dataset documentation quality assessment for Digital Curation

[Comment: I posted this without seeing Jascha's post below, hence the similar reply]
Hi, thanks for your comment! I think we can distinguish different levels of review.

The level of review that you are referring to is quite detailed, with specificities and standards of the discipline coming into play. Here I agree that real experts would be needed, and this is outside of the library's capacity. A data peer-review system proposed by Greg Scowen would be one alternative, and this actually already kind of exists in data-centered journals like https://www.earth-system-science-data.net/.

However, maybe there is a more basic level that consists in simply verifying that a basic "data archiving checklist" was performed correctly. Such a checklist would be similar to https://documentation.library.ethz.ch/display...s+for+archiving, but be more broad. Even though it is just going through a checklist, I think the screening would still be useful for scientists wanting to archive a "minimum viable product" in a hurry.

4 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

Dataset documentation quality assessment for Digital Curation

Thanks for the feedback!

4 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

Book ratings and statistics

That's right! Should I change the title to make it more clear?

4 months ago
Votes up
0
View thread

Matthew Moy de Vitry's profile

Activity for Matthew Moy de Vitry

Mini sewing kit

A complimentary caffeine pill

New ETH Mug Design

3D Printing on demand

Dataset documentation quality assessment for Digital Curation

Book ratings and statistics

3D Printing on demand

New ETH Mug Design

Book ratings and statistics

Book ratings and statistics

Dataset documentation quality assessment for Digital Curation

Dataset documentation quality assessment for Digital Curation

Dataset documentation quality assessment for Digital Curation

Book ratings and statistics

Matthew Moy de Vitry

Reputation ranking

Following